Your Cat Should Not Be Outside
Updated: Nov 19, 2023
This past summer, I was pet-sitting my neighbor’s cat and dog. It was nighttime, and I was waiting for the cat to come back inside so I could lock up and head home. When the cat came to the back door, she had something round and furry in her mouth—a mouse. After several minutes of negotiating (well, begging) I managed to convince her to drop her prey. I picked up the mouse with a plastic bag and jostled it, trying to determine if it was still alive. Its beady eyes were blank. I tied off the bag and put it in the trash, feeling somewhat disgusted and a little sad.
In the larger scheme of things, my neighbor’s cat didn’t do anything wrong. She followed her instinct to hunt, and thankfully didn’t leave much of a mess in the process. But the incident didn’t sit right with me, and as I began to learn more about outdoor cats, that one dead mouse began to represent a far greater issue.
Outdoor cats present an environmental problem that often goes overlooked. One study estimates that cats kill billions of birds and small mammals in the US each year. This figure would put cats at the largest human-influenced cause of bird death, larger than pesticides or collisions with windows. Another study calculates that cats have contributed to the extinction of 33 species worldwide through hunting and the spread of disease.
Although some may attribute these animal deaths to the circle of life, an aspect of biology, many cats are allowed to hunt and breed to the extent they do because of the protection provided by their human owners. Ornithologist Pete Marra argues that cats are an extension of the impact humans have on the environment. It is because of human pet ownership practices that other animal species are threatened. Cats may be following their biological instincts, but it is still the responsibility of the owners to regulate the effects that their pets have on the environment.
Maybe the environmental argument is not a compelling one for some cat owners. After all, outside exploration can be a form of enrichment. Some owners may value their cat’s mental wellbeing over the lives of rodents and birds. In that case, consider the cost of outdoor living to cats themselves. Outdoor cats typically live between two to five years, whereas an indoor cat’s lifespan is between ten and fifteen. Outside the home, they have an increased risk of being killed by vehicles, contracting diseases like feline HIV, or picking up fleas and ticks. No matter how stimulating exploration can be, it clearly isn’t worth the risk to a cat’s wellbeing.
There are still ways to give cats an enriched life without sacrificing their health. Some cats can be trained to wear harnesses so they can safely explore outside. Cat toys and puzzles can also provide enrichment. American Humane recommends rotating through your collection of toys every few days so cats don’t get bored. Outdoor enclosures also allow cats to get fresh air in a more controlled environment.
Even relatively low-maintenance pets like cats have certain standards for health. It requires more work on the owner’s part to create a safe and enriching environment at home instead of allowing their cat to roam free. This might be disruptive or frustrating to owners who expected less effort to be involved in taking care of a cat. But for the sake of the cat’s health and the environment, it’s worth the extra work.
Sources and Further Reading:




Comments