top of page
Search

Are electric cars really what we need?

Mar 11, 2024
3 min read



Tesla has dominated the automotive discourse for a variety of reasons, from its self-driving technology to the high prices of its cars to the unusual design of its new Cybertruck. Elon Musk has been lauded for Tesla’s success in popularizing electric vehicles (or EVs) where other companies have failed. While I agree that a shift to EVs would be a victory in the movement to decrease emissions, I’m not convinced that more Teslas are really what we need to save the world.


Cars and trucks account for about a quarter of emissions in the US, and with automobiles being a part of most Americans’ daily lives, the environmental impact of driving is often at the forefront of discussions about individual carbon footprints. Electric vehicles have been one of the more popular alternatives in the United States because they do not produce emissions.


However, not all electric vehicles are created (or driven) equally. Despite their lack of emissions, EVs draw power from grids that burn coal and oil. EVs that run off these grids are still cleaner than gas-powered cars, but the reduction in emissions is not as significant. However, in countries like France and Norway that rely on near-zero carbon sources for electricity, the reduction in emissions is much greater. It’s also worth noting that electric vehicles produce more emissions than gas-powered cars during the manufacturing stage, but over the vehicle’s lifetime, EVs are still the cleaner option. Implementing changes like the solar panel roof on Tesla’s California Gigafactory can also mitigate emissions produced by manufacturing.


The popularization of electric vehicles is definitely a victory in the clean energy movement. However, the individualization of clean transport and the focus on consumer-driven vehicles or Tesla’s upcoming “robotaxi” are missing a key aspect in revolutionizing transportation. These new machines focus on the consumer and not the collective; understandably so for a company like Tesla. Automotive sales netted the company $18.69 billion in 2022. Tesla doesn’t just sell prestige or self-driving technology; it sells a lighter conscience to more environmentally-conscious drivers.


In contrast, trains and other modes of public transportation are not nearly as profitable. Passenger rail systems in the United States typically lose money in the course of their operations, with the New Jersey-Pennsylvania PATCO rail losing about $4.47 per passenger. A lack of accessibility and long ride times have made trains less appealing to those who can afford to drive to their destination. From an aesthetic standpoint, Tesla’s sleek self-driving cars are much more attractive.


Despite its lack of glamor and considerable costs, public transportation should be given more consideration. The majority of rail transit systems share the electric vehicle’s benefit of running on electricity, which means rails that are powered by clean energy generators can greatly reduce emissions in a given area. Public transportation also reduces congestion, which can cut emissions caused by vehicles crawling on the freeway.


However, the benefits of public transportation are not just environmental. Owning an electric car is a privilege available only to those who can afford a Tesla or similar vehicle. Public transportation is far less cost-prohibitive and more accessible to people with disabilities, the elderly, and those that are otherwise unable to drive. Public transportation increases access to food, employment, and medical services and encourages socialization and physical exercise. Car-dependent suburban areas also consume more energy per capita and cost more to maintain than denser urban areas.


What many clean energy advocates fail to acknowledge is that electric vehicles are not part of the endgame solution to the climate crisis. At best, they are a mitigating strategy. According to ScienceNews, the International Energy Agency found that in order to reach its 2050 goal of net-zero emissions, “EVs would need to climb from the current 5 percent of global car sales to 60 percent by 2030.” With six years to go, electric vehicles are far behind the necessary goal to make a genuine impact against the climate crisis.


The real crime here is consumption, and advocating for increased electric car sales is still advocating for consumption. We do not need new, sleek cars to replace our gas-guzzling ones. We need to rethink transportation entirely. Leaving environmentally-conscious innovation to corporations will never result in the most beneficial solution. Tesla is, at its core, a business dedicated to increasing profits, not fighting the climate crisis. Electric vehicles have a place in our future, but our changes to transportation will have to be a lot more radical if we want to have a future at all.


Sources and Further Reading:

 
 
 

Comments


Contact Me

Thanks for submitting!

© 2035 by Train of Thoughts. Powered and secured by Wix

bottom of page